The US maps out Harare’s route out of sanctions, but warns that confidence building measures are needed for bilateral re-engagement

 

By Shoshana Kedem

 

On 19 October, the US Department of State outlined the measures the government of Zimbabwe can take for Washington to end its sanctions on the country.

US officials called for President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s government to prosecute former and current regime officials responsible for corruption and human rights abuses and build back its democracy.

“We’re asking that the Zimbabwe government take meaningful noticeable material actions that strengthen the democratic processes, build the institutions back to its constitution,” the US Department of State sanctions coordinator, James O’Brien, told a press briefing.

In September the US updated its sanctions regime on Zimbabwe, which currently targets 83 Zimbabwean individuals and 37 entities, including President Mnangagwa, and his top adviser Kudakwashe Tagwirei.

Those sanctioned by the US are forbidden from travel to America, have their US assets frozen, and are prohibited from transacting with the US banking system, or having business dealings with American companies.

 

 

“[In Zimbabwe] essentially we are focused on the people who are responsible for and profit from human rights abuses, corruption and anti democratic actions,” O’Brien said.

The Department of State stresses that sanctions do not block trade and investment with non-sanctioned individuals, and are not intended to penalise the economy.

“We are always willing to work with businesses or work with those who fear sanctions are getting in the way of legitimate business activity,” O’Brien said.

Officials invited companies wishing to operate in the country to seek clarity on the restrictions if they were unsure about red lines.

“If that company wants to talk to us we’re very happy to do that. [We] spend a lot of time talking to companies so they can be comfortable in certain environments.”

The US first imposed sanctions on specific individuals in Zimbabwe during the rule of the independence icon turned authoritarian leader, the late Robert Mugabe, for undermining democratic processes, such as passing laws restricting media freedom and the right to protest.

 

 

Undermining democracy

On 15 September, the US Department of the Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control added Stephen Mutamba, Zimbabwe’s deputy police commissioner, to the sanctions list for his role in “undermining Zimbabwe’s democratic processes and institutions”, including advocating that international observers should be prevented from monitoring the 2023 elections.

“It is imperative that ZANU-PF allow full participation across the political spectrum in next year’s elections,” said under secretary of the Treasury for terrorism and financial intelligence, Brian E. Nelson, at the time.

President Mnangagwa has called for the removal of sanctions, calling them a “cancer” that eats away at the economy.

In August this year, two visiting US senate officials were tailed and circled by vehicles believed to belong to Zimbabwe’s state security forces.

The incident was an “act of intimidation” that “resonates incredibly poorly” with officials shaping sanctions policy, said Department of State officials at the 19 October briefing.

“Those are the acts of a government that does not want to be engaged,” said O’Brien.

 

 

Cost of sanctions

Since sanctions came into effect, Zimbabwe has lost access to more than $100bn in bilateral donor support, grants, and loans from the IMF, World Bank, and the African Development Bank, a 2021 report by the United Nations Special Rapporteur found.

At the height of sanctions, Zimbabwe’s GDP contracted from $6.8bn in 2001 to $4.4bn in 2008, according to the World Bank.

In 2021, Zimbabwe’s exports to the US were valued at $9.27m including iron, steel and raw commodities such as tea and tobacco, according to the UN’s Comtrade database on international trade.

The US is Zimbabwe’s single biggest donor, providing $317m in bilateral assistance to support democracy and governance, agriculture, and health programmes in 2021, in addition to $51m in humanitarian aid.

Meanwhile the Zimbabwe Anti-Sanctions Movement (ZASM) is suing Zimbabwean opposition party leaders – Advocate Nelson Chamisa, Tendai Biti and others for damages caused upon Zimbabwe and its citizens resulting sanctions imposed on the country by a coterie of western countries.

A statement released this week said that ZASM will file civil action at the Zimbabwe High Court (within days) to hold CCC leader Chamisa, Biti, and others “… liable for damages caused upon civilian lives and the Zimbabwean economy by unlawful United States, European Union, Britain, Canadian and Australian sanctions.”

The action is based on evidence gathered over several years by the ZASM – including the recent report from the United Nations Special Rapporteur, and the admissions by one Tongai Matutu (a member of the opposition who admitted to lobbying for unlawful sanctions to sabotage the Zimbabwean economy to win votes).

The admissions, and the report – viewed together – proved that unlawful unilateral economic coercive sanctions had caused harm to innocent Zimbabwean civilians and the economy, to achieve the opposition, and the United States’ political objectives, the statement said.

 

 

ZASM quoted an October 28 2021 report on the negative impact of sanctions by the UN Special Rapporteur – for the negative impact of coercive economic measures upon Zimbabwe which had resulted in the country losing in excess of US$100 billion due to the total impact of sanctions.

Meanwhile, Nelson Chamisa himself had reportedly said during campaigning that the cost of getting infrastructure to pre-sanctions standards in Zimbabwe would cost in excess of US$24 billion.

Additionally, Zimbabwean Minister of Finance, Mthuli Ncube, had said that the Zimbabwean economy has lost over US$46 billion before calculating the ripple effect of sanctions on the whole country.

“The Zimbabwe Anti-Sanctions Movement shall therefore embark on a lawful exercise to quantify the damages incurred by these illegal sanctions on Zimbabwe, and ask the courts to hold those responsible to account for their actions.”

“ZASM joins SADC, the AU, like-minded countries, and organisations in condemning the unlawful sanctions and crimes upon humanity imposed upon Zimbabwe by illegal sanctions senders, in a manner inconsistent with the United Nations Charter,” the statement said.

ZASM said that it could leave no stone unturned in fighting for justice and equality for the people of Zimbabwe, and called on the United States of America to remove them, and the Banking Association of South Africa, together with its constituent banks, to stop defending unlawful sanctions on Zimbabwe.

 

Additional reporting: www.https://african.business/

 

 

 

Sanctions On The Agenda As President Ramaphosa Meets Joe Biden In Washington

 

Simba Chitando Sues US President Joe Biden, Financial Institutions and Banks Over Sanctions

 

Sanctions Are Real, They Have Ravaged Zimbabwe, And It’s Not Cheap Politicking

 

Twitter:@realdigitalnews
Facebook: Zimbabwe Digital Express

 

Zimbabwe Digital Express

Contact: (+27) 834767918

 

 

See News Differently
Facebook: Zimbabwe Digital Express
Twitter: @realdigitalnews